The title of this post is one of those questions that probably makes people roll there eyes. I don’t mean physically removing their eyes and rolling them around on the ground. That would be gross. And painful. And not a very effective way to show frustration. What I’m saying is, a lot of people might say “Really? We’re having THIS conversation?”
Then again, others might read that title and say “Of COURSE Christians shouldn’t celebrate Halloween unless they’re into worshiping SATAN.”
Still others might just react with a simply “Huh?”
In this episode we cover the topic of Halloween from a variety of angles. Where did the tradition come from? How should Christians feel about it? And what’s Reformation Day all about? Take a listen and join the conversation.
The StoryMen episode 34: TRICK OR TREASON?
Bonus Extra!
JR. and myself welcomed friend of the show and producer Aaron Kretzman in to talk about the smash hit movie GRAVITY. Check out that episode at StoryMen Extra: Gravity.
Join the Storyverse!
- Rate & Subscribe on iTunes.
- Connect with us at theĀ Storymen Facebook page.


4 replies on “Should Christians Celebrate Halloween?”
Great episode. Loved the discussion around Halloween and the pagan origins of most Christian holidays. Or at least the timing of them anyway.
I grew up in a church that did a “harvest party”, but it was awesome! Every room in the church was packed w/ games and it was like an indoor fair. Bobbing for apples, balloon darts, bean bag toss, dunk tank, the works.
The church we attend now holds an annual event near Halloween called “Fallapalooza”, it’s basically a Halloween bash, but without the ghosts and ghouls. They have live music, pie-eating contests, gourmet food trucks, hay ride, inflatables, face painting, etc.
It provides a safe alternative to walking around the neighborhood at night asking strangers for candy. The community has a blast and the event grows every year.
And I’m not opposed to Halloween. Yes, the origin of the holiday is pagan, but so is Christmas and even the timing of Easter. I say educate kids, steer clear of the sexy/scary costumes and have fun with it. Such a great opportunity to create connections with people who knock at your door.
And give out the big candy bars if it’s in your budget.
Hey Clay,
Two quick things.
1. You might get more comment interaction if people could see them. http://glui.me/?i=8lxx3p4jfvggme9/2013-10-30_at_4.50_AM.png/
2. Please please please ditch the 1:15 minute intro on Storymen podcast. It was funny the first time, but having to fast forward every episode is getting a little tedious. I just want to get to y’all.
Tx for the feedback KC. I know the comments are jacked up. Had it fixed once then it reverted. Frustrating & I have zero ability w/ code. Need time to work with someone. But changing many things this December anyway.
Good thoughts KC. I’m with you on the Harvest Party, always enjoyed mine. Never felt like Halloween was something to avoid.